Welcome to Another West Coast Blog! As a first time blogger with a passion for sports debate, I felt compelled to offer up my takes, ideas and facts about the sports world that encompasses us all. This blog (for the most part) will be dedicated to exposing the evil that is the East Coast bias, and its stranglehold on sports fans and the majority of sports media. I aim to bring enlightenment to the globe (if possible) that the West coast is more than beaches, celebrities and great weather.
With the long and drawn out CFB bowl season coming to a close I'd like to shed light on the biggest myth in all of organized sports: The National Championship. In 1936 the AP released its first poll containing College Football's "National Champion". Today the AP is accompanied by the Bowl Championship Series standings, both crown a "National Champion" for College Football. While the AP consists of sports writers and a "human vote", the BCS is a series of mathematical equations and percentages that give us two teams to compete for the BCS Championship.
Let me stress that again. The BCS selects two teams to compete for the BCS Championship. Before the BCS the AP selected its "National Champion" based on a vote of who the best team was. Since there has never been a playoff to decide the National Champion, how can any of us determine who really was the best team in College Football in any year? The answer: We can't. Until there is a playoff in College Football we will continue to crown a "National Champion" based on a beauty contest (Media and Coaches Polls) and a series of numbers (BCS). It will remain the only major organized sport without a playoff
For those that oppose a playoff in College Football, the common belief is that the regular season is a playoff. The Utah Utes went 13-0 and will be rewarded with an HD view of the "National Championship" and a slim hope of a split championship. The argument that Utah didn't play anybody is ridiculous. 6-0 vs. teams that made bowls, and a beat down of Alabama (a heavy favorite). USC could be playing the best football of anyone in the country, and Texas has to watch the team they beat on a neutral field in Oklahoma, play for the "National Championship". What a year for playoff right?
Wrong. In my estimation, it will never happen and that my friends, is a damn shame. Why? Money. A couple years ago Kansas' Head Coach Mark Mangino cited his teams loss to Texas on some horrible calls by the ref's as a scam. "BCS made a difference in this game... dollar signs". The BCS grants 6 conferences as Automatic Qualifiers for BCS bowl games. Teams not from AQ have huge mountains to climb just to get in to a BCS game, let alone the BCS Championship.
So this year when undefeated (at the time) Boise State was sent to the Poinsettia Bowl and 4 loss Virginia Tech automatically qualified for the Orange Bowl (BCS) cries of foul went unheard. The payout for the Poinsettia Bowl winner this season was $750,000. The payout for the Orange Bowl was $17,000,000. The sad thing is Boise State could compete with Virginia Tech, but BCS big wigs have given mediocre conferences like the ACC and the Big East AQ's and therefore don't even believe Boise could hold Virginia Tech's jock strap. The relationship between conferences and bowl traditions has ruined the spirit of competition. The reason VT goes to the Orange Bowl is because the winner of the ACC has a contract with the Orange Bowl, not because their 4 losses is more deserving. Just like all the power 6 football conferences.
Solution: Playoff!
Eliminate the 6 power conferences.
The top 8 teams enter a playoff to determine a true National Champion (1st ever). Popular belief says that determining team 8 over team 9 is the same as the BCS determining team 2 over team 3. Wrong again. The debate for 8th place and 9th place in the polls will not be the same as 2 vs 3. At the end of the year there are a legit 4 or 5 teams that can win it all. Pitting 8 vs 9 is a waste.
Seed the teams and place them in bowls geographically, adding say the Holiday Bowl and the Cotton Bowl which would always be quarterfinal bowls along with 2 BCS bowls. The 4 BCS bowls rotate between quarters and semi finals each year with the final being the National Championship. (BCS bowls also rotate for this honor each year. Based on this season's final BCS standings my playoffs would look like this:
Oklahoma vs Penn State @ Cotton Bowl
Florida vs Texas Tech @ Orange Bowl
Texas vs Utah @ Holiday Bowl
Alabama vs USC @ Fiesta Bowl
1 vs 8 against 4 vs 5 in Rose Bowl
2 vs 7 against 3 vs 6 in Sugar Bowl
National Championship Game at Rotating BCS Bowl.
While the system isn't error proof, it does offer up a scenario in which an 8 team playoff occurs without ruining the integrity of the major bowl games. Other teams that qualify for "non championship" bowls can receive a capped payout amount. Most schools that have financial advantages over others receive most of their money from boosters anyways.
So when you see either Oklahoma or Florida holding up that crystal football tonight remember that it is the BCS championship, and NOT a National Championship. We have never known a true National Champion, and until there is a playoff we will continue to be deprived.
Greed is the drive behind College Football, not providing a clear cut National Champion.